Baltimore Orioles: Four-run first inning sinks Chris Tillman

Chris Tillman put the Baltimore Orioles in a pickle last night. Not just with regard to last night’s game, but moving forward as well. Series’ at Fenway Park aren’t easy on visiting teams. The fact that Tillman made an early exit from the game could tax the bullpen going forward. Tillman’s line: 2.0 IP, 7 H, 6 R, 2 BB, 0 K.

The O’s took an early 1-0 lead thanks to Adam Jones sac fly-RBI. But that’s as close as the Birds got. Boston would tie the game in the bottom of the first with a sac fly-RBI of their own, and then Nunez’s three-run homer would give them a quick 4-1 lead.

Betts’ RBI-double in the second would add to Boston’s lead, and after hitting a batter to load the bases with nobody out in the third, Tillman would hit the showers. A run would score after he left on a wild pitch, which closed the book on Chris Tillman for the game. Tillman wasn’t fooling anyone during his outing, and as a result was asked after the game if perhaps his problems  were stemming from issues with his mechanics (all quotes courtesy of Roch Kubatko, MASNsports):

I mean, there might be. It didn’t feel like it. I felt like my last start was worse mechanically than this one. It comes down to execution. When you miss with the first one, you’ve got to try to get back into the count and you fight an uphill battle at that point, especially against a team like this. You’ve got to stay ahead and work with the count in your favor.

The good news is that the Orioles’ ‘pen really stepped up and held Boston at bay after that. Boston would scorer once more on a wild pitch in the sixth, which really just drives home the point that if you get runners on base good things might happen. The Birds would net two more runs in the seventh on Machado’s two-RBI double, but Boston shut them down other than that.

To add injury to insult, the Orioles lifted Jonathan Schoop from the game in the seventh inning after he felt a twinge in his side while swinging. This according to manager Buck Showalter:

He had some discomfort in his side and we decided to get him out of there to be on the safe side. That last swing he took.

While Schoop is struggling a bit at the plate, the O’s don’t want to lose him. According to the Orioles last night, his status in the lineup today is very much in question. It’s definitely something to watch.

The series continues this afternoon at Fenway Park. Alex Cobb will make his Orioles’ debut and first start of the season, and he’ll be opposed by Boston’s Hector Velazquez. Game time is set for just after 1 PM.

Baltimore Orioles head to the Fens for the weekend

The Baltimore Orioles will make their maiden voyage to Fenway Park (or “Pahk”) in Boston this weekend as they get set for a weekend showdown with the Boston Red Sox. Boston of course is fresh off of taking two-of-three from New York this week, in a series that featured multiple theatrics. The O’s of course dropped two-of-three to Toronto at home this week, but hope to rebound in Boston.

The Birds had their own dust-up with Boston last year under somewhat similar circumstances. As I said yesterday, the difference is that the Machado slide on Pedroia was a hard slide, but clean. The Austin slide was dirty. Granted that’s my view, but sliding in with your spikes up is a big no-no.

And the situation between Boston and New York isn’t over with yet. The teams have 16 more meetings this year. And Boston never forgets. So…based on what happened over the weekend, will their memories of last year creep up this weekend with the Orioles? One would hope not.

Needless to say, this is a big early-season series at Fenway Park for the Birds. You hope for a split; but we also said that last weekend in the Bronx. So, could the Birds take three-of-four from Boston? The answer of course is yes – if they perform at a similar level as they did last weekend.

This is a bit of a strange series in that it includes Monday’s Patriot’s Day game, which begins at 11 AM. A few years ago the Orioles played a series like this one, and it included a Sunday Night game on ESPN, AND the Patriot’s Day matinee. 11 AM is a rough time for a game at any point, however especially after a night game the day before. Perhaps not so much after a 1 PM game on Sunday, as is the case this year.

Chris Tillman gets the start in the first game of the series tonight. He’ll be opposed by Boston’s Eduardo Rodriguez. Game time is set for just after 7 PM.

Baltimore Orioles: In this game there are unwritten codes

There’s one big difference between what happened between Boston and the Baltimore Orioles last year, and what happened between them and the NY Yankees. Manny Machado did nothing more than take a hard slide into second base, however his foot hit the bag and popped up to spike Dustin Pedroia. NY’s Tyler Austin slid into second with his spikes up to begin with against Brock Holt.

Baseball has unwritten codes. While people love to rail against them and say they shouldn’t exist, they do. And they always will. Austin caused the situation at hand because of sliding in with his spikes up. Sorry to all of the folks who say there should be no unwritten codes; but that’s a big no-no.

Again, people are comparing this to Manny Machado last year. He spikes were up, but they only popped up after he made contact with the bag. There’s a big difference between that and sliding in with your spikes up from the get go. That show intent on the part of Austin.

Austin of course was hit by a pitch later in the game, prompting a benches-clearing brawl on the field. And I have no issue with that, as the fact of the matter is that in accordance with the unwritten rules Boston had the right to do it. Tyler Austin can slam his bat to the ground and complain all he wants, but he started this by spiking an opponent.

Again folks, don’t tell me that the unwritten codes are bad for baseball or that they shouldn’t exist. There are unwritten rules in all walks of life. If you go to a wedding, do you bring your dog with you? Of course not; you leave Fido at home, or make boarding arrangements if need be. But do most wedding invitations say specifically that you can’t bring a dog with you? No…because people are assuming that everyone knows not to do that. Thus it’s an unwritten rule.

So you can say you don’t agree with having unwritten rules, but they exist in all parts of one’s life. And when you violate one, you aren’t exactly looked upon with grace. So if you’re scoring at home, New York was the aggressor in this scenario. You don’t slide into second base with your spikes up like that. Am I suggesting that the hitting of Austin later in the game was justified? That’s exactly what I’m suggesting.

Baltimore Orioles: Jonathan Schoop breaks out in victory

Jonathan Schoop may have gotten his bat going in this evening’s Baltimore Orioles win over Toronto. We won’t know if Schoop’s 2-for-4 game is the beginning of a trend or just an exception until a few games down the line, but Schoop was good this evening. As was starter Kevin Gausman, who won his first game of the year this evening. Gausman’s line: 6.0 IP, 6 H, 3 R, 3 BB, 7 K.

Gausman started in an inauspicious manner, giving up a solo homer to Pillar in the first inning. And that lead held up for Toronto – until the fourth. Schoop’s RBI-double tied the game at one, which was followed by an RBI-single by Chris Davis – who also broke out a bit this evening. Beckham would add a sac fly-RBI later in the inning, and the Birds took a 3-1 lead onward.

Toronto would battle back a bit in the fifth with an RBI-single by Solarte. But the likes of Schoop, Davis, and Gausman weren’t about to let the Birds fall in this one. Schoop smacked an RBI-single in the bottom of that fifth inning, giving the Birds a 4-2 lead. Diaz would smack a homer in the sixth for Toronto, and the O’s would close the scoring with a Sisco RBI-single.

At the end of the day, it goes as a 5-3 lead for the Birds. For the record, this goes as a quality start for Gausman, who started slow this season. But his start last weekend in Yankee Stadium was a bit better, and this one was stellar. As I’ve said before, pitchers are going to have poor starts. But they’re also going to have good ones like this. Gausman picked up his offense tonight in a sense, although the offense came through as well.

Davis and Schoop have been the subject of several taunts from fans and so forth, as they’ve been slow out of the gate. But they both came through tonight. If the Orioles can get those two guys going for good, they’ll really be in good shape.

One concern coming out of this game was that Trey Mancini got nicked on the hand with a ball. His hand immediately started swelling, although he stayed in the game until the top of the ninth. X-rays were negative after the game, however tomorrow’s off day comes at a good time for Mancini. Based on production thus far, he isn’t a guy that the O’s can afford to lose.

Baltimore Orioles: Bats only used on the road?

The Baltimore Orioles got a great effort out of starter Andrew Cashner last night, but it wasn’t enough. Of late, that’s seemed to be the case when it comes to their starting pitching. As the season got rolling we thought it would be the hitting that carried the team. While there have certainly be games where the starters have struggled, the starting pitching has been more consistent than the hitting thus far. Cashner’s line: 7.0 IP, 4 H, 0 R, 3 BB, 6 K.

However the strange thing is that Oriole bats were very active this past weekend in the Bronx. The Orioles were being no-hit last night into the eighth inning. Is it the cold? It might be easy to point to that, but it was colder in NYC this past weekend than it is in Baltimore right now. And manager Buck Showalter isn’t about to fall back on that excuse (quote courtesy of Roch Kubatko, MASNsports):

That’s an excuse that our guys won’t use. You look up on the scoreboard and somebody’s scoring a bunch of runs in cold weather. It’s the conditions we play in and in the past we’ve got some guys with a track record that that hasn’t affected. I don’t think that’s going to come into it. I know the people who came out for the game tonight really don’t want to hear it.

The O’s thus far are just one of those very rare teams that doesn’t play very well at home, but okay on the road. And while you play as many road games as you do home games, that’s kind of a problem. You want to protect your home field so to speak. Buck Showalter also pointed out that quite a few Orioles squared balls up well last night and were robbed. So it isn’t as if guys aren’t hitting the ball well, teams are just playing good defense against the O’s.

While the O’s were being no-hit, Toronto couldn’t muster much either. The teams played to a scoreless draw through seven innings. Toronto would put a run across in the eighth on a throwing error to take a 1-0 lead. However once they got their fist hit, the O’s came right back. Sisco’s RBI-single tied the game at one. However in the end, it was a mislocated O’Day pitch that did the O’s in. Granderson smacked a solo homer against him in the ninth, and Toronto went home winners at 2-1.

The Birds had a flurry of chances in those final two innings, but could only muster one run out of a bases loaded situation. And yes, Toronto set their defense almost perfectly. That should tell the Orioles that their hitters are becoming too predictable. Sometimes spectacular defensive plays aren’t made fully by sheer skill and a bit of luck. Sometimes it’s also due in part to the fact that the defense was set up right where the batter usually hits the ball. And that’s part of what’s happening with the O’s.

The O’s will try to salvage one game in this series and homestand this evening at Camden Yards. Kevin Gausman gets the start for the Birds, and he’ll be opposed by Toronto’s Marco Estrada. Game time is set for just after 7 PM.

Baltimore Orioles: Is Nestor Cortes hurting the team?

Nestor Cortes Jr. gave up the decisive runs, specifically a grand slam in the ninth inning of tonight’s Baltimore Orioles game against Toronto. But that’s not why I ask if he’s hurting the O’s. In fact, perhaps the better question is whether or not the Orioles are hurting themselves by keeping Cortes on the roster – but more on that in a moment.

Dylan Bundy turned in his third consecutive quality start for the Orioles, and the third consecutive quality start in which he missed out on a win that he deserved. Bundy’s line: 7.0 IP, 4 H, 2 R, 2 BB, 10 K. It’s strange to call someone a hard-luck loser for a team that lost 7-1 but that would describe Bundy’s outing tonight. Unequivocally, he pitched well enough to win.

Bundy made one bad pitch – and it ended up being a two-run homer by Pearce, giving Toronto a 2-0 lead in the third. However the O’s came right back in the bottom of the inning on a Machado solo homer to cut the lead in half. But that’s as close as they got.

Cortes inherited a bases-loaded situation in the ninth, and promptly walked in a run to make the score 3-1. That brought Donaldson to the plate, with the bases still loaded. And unfortunately for the O’s, they were unable to walk that one last tight rope, and Donaldson deposited that ball in the stands. The grand slam gave Toronto a 7-1 victory. The final score obviously isn’t indicative of how close the game was in truth, but it goes as a six-run loss.

Going back to Nestor Cortes, we know that the Orioles under Dan Duquette have been big on the Rule 5 draft. Obviously they also have Anthony Santander (who’s Rule 5 status expires next month) and Pedro Araujo on the roster as Rule 5 draftees. And we know their history of Rule 5 players since 2012.

Araujo’s been fairly solid thus far, and Santander’s been great. Cortes has had some struggles, and quite frankly if the Orioles could send him down and keep him they probably would. But they can’t do that, or he goes back to the Yankees’ organization.

Is this mentality not potentially hurting the team, however? The fact that Cortes was the last one left on the bench in yesterday’s 12-inning game is telling. The O’s would have rather used guys who were over-taxed.

Again, this isn’t a knock on Cortes as much as it might sound like it is. I do think he has a promising career ahead of him in the big leagues. But the road’s very tough from his standpoint right now. Wouldn’t it do the player (Cortes) justice by letting him go back and further season himself in the minors? Consequently, would that not do the team justice in terms of giving them a roster spot that was more interchangeable?

I’m not suggesting that the O’s shouldn’t participate in the Rule 5 draft. I’m saying that they probably shouldn’t be quite as stubborn about keeping the players they select as they are. If someone isn’t cutting it, that’s not a knock on him. It just means he might not have been ready. So is it serving anyone by keeping him?

The series with Toronto continues tomorrow night. Andrew Cashner gets the start for the O’s, and he’ll be opposed by Toronto’s Aaron Sanchez. Game time is set for just after 7 PM.

Baltimore Orioles, Richard Bleier make the Empire State lay low

There’s nobody on the Baltimore Orioles, or the New York Yankees for the matter, who deserved to be the winning pitcher in this afternoon’s game than Richard Bleier. Nobody. Bleier wasn’t even supposed to pitch today, except perhaps in an emergency. That emergency came, in the form of a twelve inning game. And Bleier was true to the challenge.

Mike Wright Jr. had a disastrous start, which saw him not even make it out of the first inning. Wright’s line: .2 IP, 5 H, 5 R, (2 earned), 1 BB, 1 K. You might suggest that two earned runs in the first inning doesn’t exactly look “disastrous.” However when runners get on base that represent potential unearned runs, you still have to worry about them. Wright didn’t do that.

So the Orioles and Wright spotted New York a 5-0 lead. However the O’s would start their comeback attempt almost immediately, as Anthony Santander got them on the board in the second with an RBI-single. And the Orioles chipped away from there – which is what good teams do when they get behind early on.

Tim Beckham would add an RBI-single in the third, and Danny Valencia‘s two-run homer in the fifth brought the Orioles to within 5-4. A Romine RBI-single would put NY back ahead by two in the last of the fifth, just to prove that the Orioles weren’t the only scrappy team in the ballpark this afternoon.

However the Birds came right back in response to New York’s answer. Manny Machado‘s RBI-single in the sixth would bring them back to within a run at 6-5. And one inning later the Orioles would take the lead when Santander smacked his first career home run, this a two-run shot. That was a huge lift for the team, as they proved to themselves that this was a game they could win.

Romine’s RBI-single in the last of the seventh would tie it at seven, however. This game also saw some strange plays with the Orioles in the field, however the Birds answered the bell every time. Stanton lined into a 6-3 double-play to end the sixth, and Judge decided to try to swipe second base in the last of the eighth – and was thrown out. Judge may be a lot of things, but a base stealer he is not.

The O’s brought Bleier in to pitch the ninth, and as I said above he wasn’t supposed to pitch today. Buck Showalter said that he wanted to stay away from him if possible. The fact is that it wasn’t possible. And Bleier mowed New York hitters down – big time. He was helped by an amazing over-the-shoulder catch in left by Craig Gentry, which saved the winning run from crossing in the last of the tenth. But Bleier was perhaps the best pitcher in a game that featured almost every pitcher on each roster. And there’s no doubt that he brings the right attitude with him into every game he pitches (quote courtesy of Roch Kubatko, MASNsports):

I told Buck I had nine years in the minor leagues, so I had nine years off. I’ll pitch every day the rest of the year. I really don’t care. As long as I’m in the big leagues, I’m available.

Showalter said that he kind of looked like a starter out there. And perhaps he did – in the sense that he put his team in a spot to win the game. That’s what you ask of your starters. Bleier isn’t a starter, but the team needed him today in a tough spot. And he answered the call big time.

The Birds would record a quick out in the twelfth, with Bleier still the pitcher or record. Alvarez would draw a walk as a pinch-hitter, and Santander would get aboard with a seeing-eye single. That brought Gentry to the plate, and his sharp liner to the left side found left field, and left the Orioles with an 8-7 lead in extra innings.

Unfortunately for the Orioles however, closer Brad Brach struggled in the last of the twelfth. He issued two walks, and then muffed fielding Romine’s sac bunt to the left of the pitching mound. Everyone was safe, and New York had the bases loaded with nobody out. Things didn’t look good for the boys from the Old Line State, but the bases loaded does give the defense one often overlooked but very big advantage…

…there’s a force at every base. And while Brach committed a pretty bad error to achieve that force at every base, he also got an opportunity to redeem himself. And that set the moment for the third and final oddity with the O’s in the field.

Judge sent a tapped back to Brach, who fielded it cleanly in his glove. He flipped it to Calep Joseph for a force at the plate, who then threw it to Machado covering third base for a 1-2-5 double-play. That in and of itself is pretty impressive, because 1-2-5 double-plays don’t happen often. However the fact that Brach had the wherewithal to throw the ball home, and Joseph the same wherewithal to throw to third was pretty special. Brach had the opportunity to atone for his mistake, and he did. He also struck out the next hitter to end the game.

Had they lost this game, the O’s would have split the series in New York. But in winning they were able to take three-of-four, which is a much better result. And these were hard-fought games – make no mistake about it. A team of lesser character and skill wouldn’t have won them. Brach easily could have given in after his mistake. He didn’t, and it sealed a hard-fought win. Bleier easily could have gotten knocked around and blamed lack of rest. He didn’t, and he helped win the game and series.

The O’s now head home for a short three-game homestand against Toronto. Dylan Bundy gets the call for the O’s, and he’ll be opposed by Toronto’s J.A. Happ Game time is set for just after 7 PM.

Baltimore Orioles: Playing under protest

The Baltimore Orioles found themselves in a situation Friday night where manager Buck Showalter informed the umpires that the team was officially playing under protest. This is something that’s while totally legal in accordance with MLB rules and regulations, rarely happens so much anymore. And on the off chance that a team plays under protest, the protest is usually not upheld.

You know the situation of which I speak; the rundown play on the third base line Friday night. Without detailing the situation itself once again since I presume everyone knows what happened, the umpiring crew found their decision at odds with the rule book. According to the MLB rule book, the definition of a protested game is as follows:

Managers can protest a game when they allege that the umpires have misapplied the rules. The umpires must be notified of the protest at the time the play in question occurs and before the next pitch or attempted play begins. If the play in question ended the game, a protest can be filed with the league office until noon the following day. No protests are permitted on judgment calls by the umpires.

Major League Baseball’s executive vice president of baseball operations later determines whether the protested decision violated the rules, though the game will not be replayed unless it is also determined that the violation adversely affected the protesting team’s chances of winning.

On Friday, Rule 5.09 should have come into play, which details almost the exact scenario that unfolded on the field. In short, when the trail runner stepped on third, he had run past the lead runner per the rules. So he should have been out.

But that’s not how the umpires saw things, and to their credit this was admitted after the game through crew chief Jerry Meals. Following that incident, the next New York hitter recorded the third out of the inning, which ended the threat. In sum, if the Orioles had lost that game it would not have been due to the misinterpretation or oversight of the rule.

That in and of itself means that the protest probably wouldn’t have been upheld. While certainly a violation, it wouldn’t have been a violation that “adversely would have impacted the Orioles’ chances of winning the game.” Point being, you can’t play a game under protest and then think it’s ultimately going to be replayed. And there’s a lot of confusion about that, incidentally.

The fact is that there’s a lot of confusion about playing under protest overall, which probably stems from the fact that it doesn’t happen too often. As is stated above, the manager of the offended team has to formally tell the umpire that he’s playing under protest. The umpire then literally draws an imaginary letter P in the air, which indicates to the official scorer that the game is being played under protest. After the game the offended manager can either let the matter drop, or file the formal protest paperwork with the league, at which point it’s judged by the league office.

If the league decides that in fact there was a misinterpretation of the rules in some manner which led to a team’s chances of winning being lessened, the game is ordered replayed from that point onward. And if not, the result stands. As you can imagine, there are many times when managers play under protest but they end up winning the game – in which case they don’t file the paperwork with the league and the matter drops.

Let’s say that the subsequent New York hitter in Friday’s game had come into score and NY had won the game 4-3. Then I think you would have a very legitimate case in front of the league office whereby the umpires botching the rules would have made it more difficult for the Birds to win. You very well could have had a situation where the result was thrown out and the game would have been resumed in the top of the seventh with a 3-3 tie. The umpires’ apology backs this up.

More confusing perhaps is the question of what is and is not “protestable.” You can never play under protest after a judgement call. So fair/foul, out/safe, and obviously balls and strikes cannot result in the game being played under protest. Those are considered judgement calls by the umpires. And make not mistake that the umpire may be wrong in any given circumstance on the call. But it’s still a judgement call on his part.

The situation the other night saw a rule incorrectly applied – or more realistically not applied. If it’s a case where a rule is misinterpreted, incorrectly used (or not used), etc, that is a situation where a team can play under protest. So it’s a very fine line to walk in a sense. First the rule has to have been botched. Then it has to be proven that the team’s chances of winning were adversely affected. So you can see why this comes off as such a novel concept, because it’s not used often and when it does it isn’t usually successful.

However I’m glad that baseball has this method in the rule books. The umpires aren’t perfect, and the fact is that there are a lot of rules to know. So why not put a safety measure into the rules which allow for a team to have it’s case heard when they feel something’s been done incorrectly? The goal is to get the call correct. This further allows the league to do that.

Baltimore Orioles: Walks haunt Chris Tillman

Chris Tillman posted a much better effort for the Baltimore Orioles this afternoon at Yankee Stadium than last time out. He had his struggles in this one, but ultimately he put the Orioles in a spot to win following a marathon game on Friday night. Tillman’s line: 5.1 IP, 8 H, 5 R, 4 BB, 3 K.

Again, he wasn’t perfect. The Orioles need him to go deeper into the games. But he pitched better than the numbers indicate. Tillman gave up two early runs in the second on a two-RBI single by Gardener, however had the ball not ticked off of Chris Davis‘ glove, odds are two don’t score.

But the Orioles came right back. Manny Machado smacked a two-RBI double in the third, and Pedro Alvarez an RBI-double in the fourth. And before you know it, Tillman and the O’s held a 3-2 lead.

However Tillman issued walks in the last of the fifth and the sixth. Both led to New York runs. Judge would bat in a run on a ground out in the fifth inning, and Andujar’s sac fly-RBI would give New York the lead on the last of the sixth. Both runs came off of walks, the one in the sixth inning coming after a lead off walk.

The Orioles have to cut down on free passes if they’re going to be successful this season. That’s been their bugaboo for some time. Now I will say that neither Tillman nor any subsequent Oriole pitcher was given the benefit of the doubt on borderline pitches. They were all called balls. But when you’re giving the impression of nibbling, you aren’t going to get those calls.

Romine would add an RBI-single later in the sixth. Judge’s RBI-double would then run the score to 6-3 in favor of New York. Austin would add a two-RBI single as well, running the final to 8-3. This is a tough game to lose for the O’s because of the quick turnaround after last night. However the good news is that they’re still in good shape to take the series tomorrow afternoon.

Incidentally, I made mention of a few borderline pitches that were called balls against Oriole pitching. First off keep in mind that balls and strikes are judgement calls. The idea is that you want the umpire to be consistent, and for the most part he was. But when you’re trying to hit the black on the plate, you’re leaving things open to interpretation.

The series finale is tomorrow from Yankee Stadium. Mike Wright Jr. gets the start for the Birds, and he’ll be opposed by New York’s Jordan Montgomery. Game time is set for just after 1 PM.

Baltimore Orioles: Pedro Alvarez leaves the Empire State in his grand wake

Next time someone asks who won the most recent New York Marathon, you can say the Baltimore Orioles – thanks to Pedro Alvarez. This is obviously a play on words, but it was Alvarez’s grand slam in the 14th inning that lifted the Birds to victory for the second consecutive game against the New York Yankees. And this time around, they may have severely wounded their opponent.

Kevin Gausman was strong for the Birds on the mound, in what seems like ages ago as the starter. Gausman’s line: 5.0 IP, 5 H, 2 R, 1 BB, 3 K. Obviously you want your starter going deeper than that. But with how this game turned out, it was really beside the point. Especially on a night that saw New York potentially lose both Sabathia and Chapman to injury, and one in which the O’s ripped through their bullpen.

The Orioles never trailed in this game, although it sure was tied for awhile. Manny Machado‘s solo homer in the first inning gave them the lead, although NY would immediately tie it in the bottom of the inning on a Stanton sac fly-RBI. However Machado would come up again in the third, smacking his second solo homer of the game, and giving the O’s the lead back at 2-1.

But again NY matched them. Judge’s RBI-single in the bottom of that third inning would tie the game once again at two. But wouldn’t you know it, the O’s were going off the grid in this one. Chris Davis seemingly decided to apparently break his slump with his first homer of the season, a solo shot of his own in the fourth. Of course, NY would tie it with a Gregorious solo homer in the eighth – and we played on.

But let me back up for a moment. I tell people all the time that when a game goes past the 12th inning it enters the twilight zone. This game definitely went into that realm, however I think it was there well before the 12th or 13th inning. Perhaps it entered the twilight zone when Sabathia had to exit with right hip soreness. Perhaps it was when Chapman almost had to leave with an injury, potentially further taxing NY’s bullpen. But my vote is that it entered the twilight zone with a bizarre sequence in the last of the sixth.

Long story short, with one out the Orioles caught Stanton in a rundown between third and home. Sanchez, who was previously on second, took third. Stanton was then tagged out down the left field line. Again, it was a bizarre play and in reality according to MLB Rule 5.09 clause (b)(9), it should have been a double-play.

Buck Showalter actually played under protest because the O’s weren’t awarded a double-play. However the next batter grounded out harmlessly, so the protest was dropped. However the scenario laid out in the rule almost exactly describes what happened in that play. To his undying credit, crew chief Jerry Meals basically admitted to a pool reporter after the game that his crew got this one wrong (quote courtesy of Roch Kubatko, MASNsports):

OK, what we had on the field, what Ronny (Kulpa) had on the field, was as soon as Stanton ran by him into foul territory there, he had him out for abandoning his effort, which gave Sánchez the base, so when they tagged him he wasn’t out. That was our explanation on the field. We were incorrect.

That just doesn’t happen, folks. Umpires normally don’t go into that much detail on rules and situations to begin with. But they rarely admit they were incorrect. Jerry Meals is a good veteran umpire, and it takes a lot of guts on his part to say that.

So in the wake of that play in the last of the 11th with two outs and the bases loaded, Mychal Givens uncorked a wild pitch – that probably should have ended the game. Gregorious came in from third, however the ball bounced off the grandstand and right back to Orioles’ catcher Caleb Joseph – who flipped the ball towards Givens who was trying to cover the plate.

Givens blocked the plate masterfully like an old school catcher, disallowing Gregorious from touching it. Gregorious was called out, however the play was reviewed. We know that catchers aren’t allowed to block the plate…but are pitchers? Rule 6.01 covers blocking the plate, but makes no mention of a pitcher. The call was correctly upheld, and we played on.

But what would a long night that had just about every twist and turn in the world be without a grand finish. And Pedro Alvarez gave us that, with a grand slam in the 14th inning to lift the O’s to victory. And in “grand style” at that!

This game for some reason reminded me of the 2012 18-inning win at Fenway that has Chris Davis as the winning pitcher. Ultimately it was a wild game that sprang a life of it’s own, and it took heroics from an unlikely source for the Birds to win it. On a side note, make no mistake about the fact that the Orioles heavily taxed NY’s pitching, especially their bullpen. The Orioles’ pen was used heavily as well, but New York had to use theirs for longer and more in depth. That aside, I suppose that both teams could make roster moves in their bullpens before today’s game.

The teams will get right back at it this afternoon with a matinee at Yankee Stadium. Chris Tillman gets the start for the O’s, and he’ll be opposed by NY’s Sonny Gray. Game time is set for just after 1 PM.