Shane Baz pitched well enough to win tonight for the Baltimore Orioles. And the Birds had their chances. But even the best pitcher on earth can’t win games if the team around him can’t pay attention to detail in games. That’s as Baz’s fate tonight at Yankee Stadium. Baz’s line: 5.2 IP, 5 H, 6 R (5 earned), 5 BB, 4 K.
After the O’s stranded one in the first, New York led off their half of the frame with a Grisham double. That brought up Judge, who’s always an at-bat of consequence. Baz worked Judge to a 2-2 count. He threw an 89 MPH slider, and it was called ball three.
The pitch track seemed to indicate that it caught the bottom of the box. There isn’t one person in the ballpark, or watching at home on television who thought that wouldn’t be overturned by way of an ABS challenge…
…except Adley Rutschman. To be clear, Rutschman is cerebral, which is a good thing. However the ABS system doesn’t reward that. It rewards decisiveness – right or wrong. I agree with Rutschman’s apparent conservative philosophy in terms of challenging, Play it safe, and ensure that you have an option to challenge toward the end of the ballgame.
But maybe Rutschman took that too much to heart. Again, play it safe. But that pitch was in the zone; literally every replay and pitch track showed that. It would have been strike three upon review, and the Orioles would have been out of the inning. Instead, Judge hit a two-run home run, giving New York a 2-0 lead.
Grisham would double in the third, and advance to third base on a throwing error by Leody Taveras. Bellinger’s sac fly would tack onto New York’s lead making it 3-1. Again, the result of a mental lapse.
Colton Cowser quietly had a good game at the plate. He walked in his first at-bat, and then came up with the bases loaded in the sixth. He didn’t drive the ball and net a power hit with runners in scoring position. But he didn’t drive draw a walk. And in doing so he cut the NY lead to 3-1.
In the home half of the frame New York appeared to record the final out of the inning at home plate when Baz uncorked a wild pitch and a runner from third was called out. Yet..:New York did what the Orioles didn’t. They challenged. And they won.
Somehow, they were rewarded for rolling the dice. They put two additional runs on the board before the inning ended. And six more in the eighth, defeating the Orioles 12-1. Needless to say, this was another one which got away from the O’s. The game was closer than the score indicates. But still a loss.
It’s too easy to point at that minuscule moment in the first inning – the Adley Rutschman challenge. I thought it was a strike. I thought it might have been worth challenging. I also have replay. Rutschman did not. The rules mandate that he goes out on a limb and runs a risk to potentially get a call.
Of course, Judge hit a home run. And while the final said 12-1, it wasn’t a 12-1 game – until the end. However that moment did set the tone. And it illuminates the fact that the Orioles refuse to be bold. New York, despite their talent, fights for everything. They were challenging calls late into the game, and well after the outcome wasn’t in question. They didn’t care. They weren’t about to give away outs. The Orioles weren’t sure, so true to my own philosophy, they sat on their hands.
The O’s now head to South Beach to open a three-game set with Miami at loanDepot Park. Christ Bassitt gets the start for the O’s, and he’ll be opposed by Miami’s Sandy Alcantera. Game time is set for just after 6:30 PM.
