Trey Gibson was put in an impossible position by the Baltimore Orioles today. Beat New York in the Bronx, while they’re having everything in their grasp bounce the right way. Also to be the Orioles’ stopper – this in his major league debut. In what should have been the most exciting moment of his life, he was thrown into a pressure situation. And he delivered. Gibson’s line: 4.2 IP, 3 H, 3 R, 2 BB, 2 K.
Unfortunately for Gibson, he was also pitching against New York’s Fried – their ace, and one of the best pitchers in baseball. While Fried didn’t have a great game and looked uncomfortable at times, he still is who he is. As a result, the Orioles used what I would term a less than impactful lineup, in an effort to stack the deck with all righties.
Gibson gave up two home runs. One to Rice in the first, and one to Judge in the third. Home runs are going to happen, especially to rookies the first was a solo shot – no harm no foul. The Judge home run SHOULD have been a solo shot. But Weston Wilson and Blaze Alexander almost collided in shallow left field, allowing Rice’s flair to drop as a double.
However Wilson also got aboard in the second and promptly stole second base. He would score on an RBI-single by Blaze Alexander. This of course before that defensive mishap.
The Orioles did hang around in this game. They would take advantage of Fried not being himself and load the bases with nobody out in the fourth. Leody Taveras’ infield RBI-single cut the lead to 3-2. It also kept the bases loaded, and the O’s would eventually tie it. This as Jeremiah Jackson grounded into a double-play, scoring the third run of the game for the O’s.
That was a huge moment. The Orioles could have put a crooked number up on a few different occasions, but they opted for piecemeal runs. Mind you, that’s not the worst thing – no runs would be worse. But if you play for one run, that might be all you get.
The game remained tied until the sixth when NY put a runner at third with one out. McMahon grounded to Coby Mayo at first base, who appeared to try to throw the ball home before he cleanly had it. Instead, the run scored and McMahon was safe at first base. The O’s got out of the inning without further incident, but they trailed 4-3.
That was ruled an infield RBI-single. But it’s also a play Coby Mayo has to make. Of course you want to cut off the run. It goes without saying. But you have to know when to live to fight another day. The correct play there was to take the out at first base.
New York took a one-run lead into the last of the eighth, and then exploded. They put up eight runs against Oriole pitching, resulting in an 11-3 win. Much of that against Andrew Kitteredge. The play that really glares however was once again on Coby Mayo. With two runners on, Caballero sent a swinging bunt up the third base line. Mayo I explicably tried to field the ball, presumably to make the play at first base.
It was a play he wasn’t ever going to make, despite having a good arm. However the ball was clearly rolling foul. Instead by touching the ball, it was an infield hit. And New York made the Orioles pay.
Analytics say to load your lineup with righties when you face a guy like Fried. I understand that, however is it really worth sacrificing defense for that? You leave a guy like Gunnar Henderson on the bench for that reason? I think you’re handicapping the lineup doing that.
Analytics are important. But not at the price of sound logic. Coby Mayo made two massive mistakes in this game, ironically from both corners of the infield. (He switched to third later in the game.) You can’t allow that to happen. The mistake at first led directly to New York taking the lead.
The Orioles’ front office has more data than they know what to do with. You can’t win games on computers – this isn’t Atari or Nintendo. This is baseball. Computers don’t play the game. Humans do.
Incidentally, I’m not saying that the Orioles should throw in the towel on this year. It’s too early for that. But toss the computer analytics out the Warehouse window. And maybe look around and see if a trade can be made for a veteran or someone with some experience to help steady the ship.
The series concludes tomorrow night at Yankee Stadium. Shane Baz gets the start for the Orioles, and he’ll be opposed by New York’s Cam Schlittler. Game time is set for just after 7 PM.
Birdland Crush 